A major review has found that plunging into cold water after exercise can speed recovery and boost performance in some situations - but using it after every workout could actually be detrimental to strength and muscle gains.
The findings, by Edith Cowan University's (ECU's) School of Medical Health Sciences, suggest athletes, coaches and fitness enthusiasts should be strategic rather than habitual in their use of ice baths.
"Cold-water immersion is not a one-size-fits-all recovery tool," lead author and PhD Candidate Erfan Berjisian said.
"Its benefits depend heavily on the athlete's goals, the type of exercise completed, and when the next performance session is scheduled."
The review found that ice baths are particularly effective for reducing muscle soreness, lowering markers of muscle damage and helping athletes feel recovered more quickly.
Muscle soreness was consistently reduced for up to four days after exercise, while markers of muscle damage were lower between 24 and 72 hours after an ice bath.
For athletes needing to get straight back out there, the news was even better.
"Cold-water immersion appears especially useful when recovery time is limited, such as during tournaments, congested competition schedules or repeated high-intensity training sessions," Mr Berjisian said.
Researchers found endurance performance improved within the first hour after an ice bath, while power and jump performance often improved 24 to 72 hours later.
However, there was a catch.
Explosive performance actually dropped in the hours immediately following an ice bath because of the temporary cooling effect on muscles.
"If athletes need to perform high-speed or explosive movements soon after cooling, cold-water immersion may be counterproductive unless sufficient re-warming occurs," Senior Lecturer Dr Kristina Kendall said.
Perhaps the most significant finding was the impact of repeated ice-bath use on long-term training gains.
Athletes who constantly used cold-water immersion after resistance training experienced smaller improvements in strength, muscle size and power compared with those who avoided the practice.
The evidence suggests chronic use may blunt some of the body's normal muscle-building responses to training.
The picture was different for endurance athletes. The review found no evidence that regular cold-water immersion harmed aerobic fitness or endurance adaptations.
The study also identified a "sweet spot" for recovery.
The most effective practices generally involved immersing the body in water between 10°C and 15°C for 10 to 15 minutes. Slightly colder water of 5°C to 10°C for the same duration may offer additional benefits for jump recovery and reducing muscle damage.
Researchers analysed 15 published systematic reviews and meta-analyses covering 161 studies and more than 3,200 participants, making it one of the most comprehensive examinations yet of post-exercise cold-water immersion (CWI), commonly known as ice baths.
The bottom line? Ice baths remain a powerful recovery tool when rapid recovery is the priority, but the science suggests athletes should stop viewing them as a cure-all and be more cautious when focused on building strength and muscle mass.
For some athletes, the cold plunge may be exactly what they need. For others, it could be leaving gains out in the cold.
The study, titled "Strategic Application of Post-exercise Cold-Water Immersion to Enhance Performance Recovery and Adaptation: An Umbrella Review of 15 Published Systematic Review with Meta-analysis", is published online in Sports Medicine Open.
Credit: chanakon laorob